I like jane s acts of defiance because anna paquin is a total scene stealer as young jane. When daphne dumauriers acclaimed gothic romance novel rebecca debuted in 1938, it was devoured by the female readers of its day. Jane eyre and wide sargasso sea have their obvious differences, but they are also connected in several ways. What is remarkable is how the jane eyre movies and miniseries have allowed fans of the novel to share their feelings, opinions, and. My major quarrel with some major filmed versions of jane eyre has been their length. Jane eyre also displays the familiar tropes of the gothic novel. Jane eyre by english writer charlotte bronte is an autobiographical novel in many respects. Its entirely possible that in the interest of research i have watched most of these film adaptations of jane eyre. A cursory glance through jane eyre listings at or the internet movie database reveals that almost any film version of jane eyre has its fans. There have been over sixteen english language film versions of jane eyre, beginning in 1910 with the first of eight silent movies based on the book. May 31, 2016 and yet, there are numerous attempts at jane eyre movies. Not having forgotten adele, jane visits her at school.
Jane eyre by bronte, charlotte 1890 crowell marbled. At the writing of this story, jane has been married for ten years. Because of this, a movie may differ from the novel. In comparison to, say, scorseses skillful film adaptation of edith. My goal with this website is to catalogue all the things ive found, with a focus on different film, radio, book and theatre adaptations. Mar 21, 2020 reader, did you know that there has been at least one screen adaptation of jane eyre per decade since 1910. It has a story that i can only describe as a meshing of beauty and the beast and rebecca. There have been over 50 tv or movie version of jane eyre leading back to 1910. The book is different from most of the movies just by its feel.
Oct 05, 2007 the jane austen book club is a delightful film for common viewers, but certainly wonderful for jane austens fans. Comprehensive guide to jane eyre adaptations reelrundown. Once there, she must choose whether to follow the plot of jane. Jane eyre was published in 1847 and brought fame to its author, charlotte bronte. Im a huge fan of the novel and have spent more time than i should looking up everything i could about it. Perhaps they would look down on jane eyre, but would probably get some eyebrows raised at them. In my humble opinion, in 1983, timothy dalton plays as if it is a stage scene or a teletheatre.
But it was a book that i was very enriched by reading. Ultimately, however, criticisms of dumauriers most famous novel were quick to point out its irrefutable resemblance to another gothic romance novel written nearly 100 years prior. Feb 04, 2009 the 2006 has a more atmospheric and eery tone, similar to the book, while the 1983 version is a little dated and that feel was missing for me. Widely considered a classic, it gave a new truthfulness to the victorian novel with its realistic portrayal of the inner life of a woman, noting her struggles with her natural desires and social condition. The 1983 miniseries with zelah clarke and timothy dalton covers the book most completely and accurately followed closely by the 1973 series with sorcha cusack and michael jayston. The movie versions ive seen were, surprisingly, fairly true to the book not often the case, as anyone who reads a book and then watches its movie knows. Comparison of harry potter and jane eyre 905 words.
I walked with a zombie, a val lewton horror movie loosely based on jane eyre, starring tom conway and frances dee. The jane austen book club is a delightful film for common viewers, but certainly wonderful for jane austens fans. Shy governess, obnoxiousbutphilosophical middle aged guy. And yet, there are numerous attempts at jane eyre movies.
The 2006 tv adaptation of jane eyre first premiered in the uk ten years ago on this very date. I wouldnt even recommend watching this film except to give yourself a good laugh. I have tried a few times since, again circumstances in life intervening. Comparison of the movie jane eyre and the book jane eyre essay. The focus on jane s childhood was another plus to the film. Now, theyve whipped up another ghostly journey into the past in the. A personal favourite of mine and numerous others is the tv fivepart adaptation of pride and prejudice the tv phenomenon that transformed colin firth into a sexual god overnight in the infamous. The story about love, second chance and jane austen novels has one of the most pleasant and charismatic cast that i have ever seen, with very beautiful and charming mature and young actresses and great actors having topnotch. That movie is a little short, but captures the soul of the book, by my opinion. Surely one could do little justice to brontes sprawling masterpiece in two hours 2011 jane eyre movie, much less in 97 minutes 1943 jane eyre movie or even 62 minutes 1934 jane eyre movie. Captures her passion, restraint, intelligence, understanding, the essence of jane eyre rochester as a whole character and look proposal scene the bleeding inwardly line just wrenches at ones heart wedding scene and meeting the wife pleading scenefassbender captured the extremeties in rochesters character.
There are even more if you include versions filmed in other languages, and more than that if you consider adaptations more loosely based on the story. I compare all other je adaptations that come around about every decade since to see if they match the vivid impact this version had on my young brain. Cynthia hand, brodi ashton and jodi meadows, the team of young adult authors otherwise known as the lady janies, penned the 2016 new york times bestseller my lady jane inspired more or less by hapless historical figure lady jane grey, who ruled as queen of england for only nine days. Jane eyre, the 1847 novel by english writer charlotte bronte, has frequently been adapted for film, radio, television and theatre, and has inspired a number of. Mar 10, 2011 coscripted by aldous huxley, this early adaptation of jane eyre unspools like a horror movie, all looming gothic towers, slanting shadows, and bursts of orchestral bangcrash. The first american film adaptation, a silent picture, was released in 1910 but has since been lost. Hired as a consultant by her exboyfriends grandmother, a rare book dealer finds the strength and courage to sort out her problems when she comes to haworth. Most of the characters were the same, the major events happened, and the sets were really cool. The brontes and austen grew up in different time eras, social classes, and locations and wrote about vastly different things in a different fashion. Rochester, with joan fontaine playing the title character. While it took a few more months to premiere in the us which is where i first saw it, the miniseries had already started to make its mark as arguably the definitive adaptation of charlotte brontes famed gothic novel, jane eyre.
As an orphan at gateshead, jane is oppressed and dependent. Sep 16, 2017 there have been over sixteen english language film versions of jane eyre, beginning in 1910 with the first of eight silent movies based on the book. Basically this is the only classic ive ever actually enjoyed. Jane eyre, the 1847 novel by charlotte bronte, and the 2011 film. Apr 09, 2011 the child jane amelia clarkson is sympathetic, but like her older self, played as a largely quiescent character.
In the novel, jane is scarily 20 and rochester is older. The girl is pale, thin, and unhappy, so jane moves her to a more indulgent school. Jane eyre was already next on my lit flicks challenge list, but when i happened to be the october giveaway winner and the bluestocking society kindly sent me the book thanks, jessica. Romance is a genre that is looked down on by many sophisticated readers. Litcharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in jane eyre, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. Jane as a whole character and look mia is an amazing jane. What is your view on a comparison between jane eyre and. Currently, there have been over twenty film and tv adaptations, with another film announced for 2011 featuring mia wasikowska of tim burtons alice in wonderland.
Jane eyre is a widely filmed adaptation from the charlotte bronte book of the same name. It is devoted to the story about modest, but proud and independent. Coscripted by aldous huxley, this early adaptation of jane eyre unspools like a horror movie, all looming gothic towers, slanting shadows, and. Helen burns, janes friend at lowood school, serves as a foil to mr. Every fortnight, well compare a book with its visual adaptation. A comparison between the jane eyres movie and novel nora. Compare and contrast some of the characters who serve as foils throughout jane eyre.
As a comparison, i really liked the backdrop of this movie better. Jane eyre, novel by charlotte bronte, first published in 1847. I watched the several versions of films jane eyre, i must say, 1970 tv movie, g. The performances of the young cast for jane s childhood were very memorable, adele is adorable. I like janes acts of defiance because anna paquin is a total scene stealer as young jane. It was directed by robert stevenson and produced by the uncredited kenneth macgowan and orson welles. Every true lit lover, and every jane eyre fanatic in particular, knows that tastes differ. Diana and mary both approve of her marriage, but jane receives no response from st. Before reading or seeing jane eyre, i did have some idea of the general plot. They then engage in activities designed to guide them to deeper reading of the text. When i watched the movie i thought about how different the book and the movie were. The enthusiasts guide to jane eyre is an informative website about jane eyre by charlotte bronte. A directors challenge is to make adjustments so the translation will fit accessibly in a. Though both appear to be older than they are in book, but the mental age fit seamlessly.
Pick a production and you will find it is some peoples favorite. Jul 30, 2015 as a comparison, i really liked the backdrop of this movie better. Adele grows into a docile, goodnatured young woman. Jane eyre the novel it is and leaving nothing for the actors to deliver. This definitive ranking of jane eyre adaptations will help you avoid the worst offenders, at least. Find books like jane eyre from the worlds largest community of readers. Apr 17, 2017 jane eyre was published in 1847 and brought fame to its author, charlotte bronte. When i watched the movie i thought about how different the book.
I liked the movie, its the first jane eyre adaptation ive ever seen and i like it, some pieces were missing but, im positive, theres never going to be an adaptation like pride and prejudice 1995, dont you think. Rochester, with joan fontaine playing the title character the screenplay was written by john houseman, aldous huxley, and director. Plot structure moor house jane travels from thornfield to the moor house because she has found out about bertha. Its an opportunity to map how my tastes have changed over the years. Messages to the reader in jane eyre, a novel by charlotte. I also know now that ranking jane eyre interpretations definitively is impossible. Although janes tale is a bit more intricate and emotional than the average fairy tale, the similarities. Brocklehurst embodies an evangelical form of religion that seeks to strip others of their excessive pride or of their ability to take pleasure in worldly things, helen represents a mode of christianity that stresses tolerance and acceptance. Consider the treatment of jane as a governess, but also of the other servants in the book, along with jane s attitude toward her impoverished students at morton. Throughout her life she has depended on very few people for very little.
Nov 19, 2010 jane eyre was one of the books my nan handed over. In their early childhood, both were raised as orphans, both experienced cruelty and unkind treatment from relatives who were supposed to take care of them, both were given opportunity to study and live far away from the people who treated them harshly, and both of them had a lifechanging experience in. Simple as it may seem, ranking the jane eyre adaptations anew is exciting. Although jane s tale is a bit more intricate and emotional than the average fairy tale, the similarities. It is a popular and amusing sport to compare movies to the novels from which they are adapted or derived, and, while i sometimes indulge in this game, it is folly.
Book vs film for fans of the classics jane austen, charlotte and emily bront e etc, there is little debate over the best adaptations. Based on a radio adaptation of the novel, the 1943 film focused on the romantic high points of the book and less on jane s developing sense of self. Although it was not in the book, i love it when jane cuts her hair in solidarity with helen. Jane eyre theme essay rough draft independence, the capacity to manage ones own affairs, make ones own judgments, and provide for ones self.
Producers often use a book as a springboard for a movie idea or to earn a specific rating. A picture may be worth a thousand words, but many qualities of a good novel simply cannot be transferred to film. It surprised me how i could know nothing about a book and then come out knowing everything about it. Peggy ann garner in the same role shows a lot of spunk, which helps us better understand the sturdy backbone and spirit of the adult jane eyre.
Dec 09, 20 jane s spiritual pilgrimage is also narrated with biblical simplicity, combined with considerable artifice. Jane is a governess who comes to work in a creepy house for a brooding man with a big secret. Townsend this ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. Jane eyre by charlotte bronte page to screen comparisons. The film doctor said i havent seen all of the jane eyre movie versions either, but having sampled a few, i recommend the masterpiece theater version, in part because it encompasses more of the novel, and because both the actors playing jane and rochester are convincing. I think one thing all readers forget when a beloved book comes to the screen is that what makes a good book does not always make a good movie. Ill then go over similarities and differences of note between the story told in the movie and in the book. I just started reading it and it is really good so far. Where better to start than with the classic 1943 rendition, starring. Rochester at one point, while feeling a sense of dependency and weakness linked to their feelings for him. A comparison between the jane eyre s movie and novel to each piece of work its uniqueness and beauty, and thus from the very start, i must be fair and state that both the movie and the book of jane eyre were masterpieces. For fans of the classics jane austen, charlotte and emily bronte etc, there is little debate over the best. February 22, 2019 february 21, 2019 madisondiazauthor. Harry potter and jane eyre are two novel characters who have quite a lot of similarities.
And yet i feel like i barely scratched the surface. For jane to discover herself, she must break out of these restrictive conditions and find love and independence. Jane eyre by charlotte bronte goodreads share book. This is where the movie begins, jane is found on the rivers front step. In their early childhood, both were raised as orphans, both experienced cruelty and unkind treatment from relatives who were supposed to take care of them, both were given opportunity to study and live far away. First off, most comparisons arent fair to begin with. In honor of finally finishing jane eyre, my roommate and i watched the film adaptation with mia wasikowska as the lead and michael fassbender as mr. The publication of jane eyre in 1847 heralded a new direction in prose fiction featuring. In this instalment, emma finds herself in the role of jane eyre, the book she is currently reading.
The focus on janes childhood was another plus to the film. Comparison of the movie jane eyre and the book jane eyre. The classic jane eyre is the 1944 version with joan fontaine and orson welles. Comparison of the movie jane eyre and the book jane eyre essay example. Comparison of harry potter and jane eyre 905 words bartleby. Jane eyre has been filmed many times 22, according to. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Jane eyre is an american film adaptation of charlotte brontes 1847 novel of the same name, released by 20th century fox. The theme of love, family, and independence in jane eyre. I must admit i did try jane eyre back then and was getting into it before circumstances meant i didnt do so much reading and could not get back into the story. Jane eyre jane eyre was a book and a movie that i had never heard about before. Jane eyre, by charlotte bronte the project gutenberg ebook, jane eyre, by charlotte bronte, illustrated by f. Jane eyre cliffsnotes study guides book summaries, test. Here is an examination of jane eyres film history and other.
738 1456 1192 232 639 399 34 279 64 303 752 246 786 579 206 346 1027 641 199 1470 1320 1262 1430 65 988 1334 410 1006 1280 1373 196 152 922 549 77 541 416 1327 1010 471 206 712 1025 1011 39 880 834 1406 331 945